2001-2002 Wheat Variety Trials in the Texas Panhandle

2001 – 2002 Wheat Variety Trials in the Texas Panhandle

  Brent Bean [1]

   2002 Wheat Crop

This year will not be remembered as a good wheat year.  Generally we think of the ideal time to plant wheat as  the first week of October.  This year, however, many producers elected to plant their dryland wheat early when we had good moisture.  This turned out to be a good choice for two reasons.  One, we had very little rainfall during the fall making it difficult to get later planted wheat established.  And second, greenbugs were particularly damaging to late-planted wheat that was too small to withstand heavy greenbug populations.  Even relatively low populations of greenbugs can be devastating on small wheat.  The winter and spring months provided little relief from dry weather.  A combination of drought, greenbug, and late freeze damage caused many dryland wheat fields to be abandoned.  Those that remained tended to produce below average yield.  Irrigated wheat faired better, but was an expensive crop to grow because of increased insect and irrigation costs.

In contrast to last year, this was a good year to evaluate varieties under drought conditions.  Wheat variety trials were harvested in  Dallam,  Hemphill, Castro/lamb, Potter/Randall, Armstrong, Moore, and Briscoe counties.

Wheat Variety Trial Results

Each trial consisted of a uniform set of 35 wheat varieties (see accompanying tables).  The dryland trials were established near Silverton, Claude, Bushland, Etter, and Canadian.  Irrigated trials were located near Hart, and between Dalhart and Texline.

Dryland

In the accompanying tables bold type indicates those varieties that yielded in the top 20% at each location.  In the dryland trials, varieties with greenbug tolerance; TAM 110, Above, and AP 502 CL, were consistently high performers.  Above and AP 502 CL are in a new class of wheats called Clearfield wheats.  Clearfield wheats are tolerant to the herbicide Beyond sold by BASF.  Beyond can be used to control grasses such as cheat and jointed goatgrass.  Other varieties that were in the top 20% in at least two locations were Custer, Jagaline, Jagger, Trego, Prairie Red, Stanton, TAM 105, TAM 107, and TAM 111.  TAM 105 and TAM 107 are older varieties that set the standard for dryland wheats in the Panhandle.  Although they are susceptible to many diseases, they are still very consistent performing varieties.  Prairie Red is a Colorado wheat that is essentially TAM 107 with Russian wheat aphid tolerance.  Custer is an Oklahoma variety that is a cross between TAM 105 and Chisholm and is generally considered a good dual purpose wheat.  Trego is an hard white winter wheat that has consistently been a top yielder in Panhandle trials.  However, Trego should only be grown on a contract basis since it must be kept separate from  hard red winter wheats.   This is the first year we have had Stanton in our uniform variety trial.  Stanton, released by Kansas in 2000, is similar to TAM 107 but has leaf rust and Russian wheat aphid tolerance.  Jagger is a very popular variety in Kansas.  Many producers in the Panhandle elected to plant Jagger this last growing season because of its excellent yield potential under both dryland and irrigated conditions.  Although Jagger did not perform as well this year, it still was one of the top yielding varieties.  Its biggest negative is that it tends to break dormancy early in the spring making it susceptible to late freezes.   Jagalene is an AgriPro wheat that is a cross between Jagger and an older variety that was popular a few years ago called Abiline.  Jagaline should maintain the yield potential of Jagger while holding its winter dormancy.  TAM 111 is the newest variety to be released by Texas A&M.  The variety should have excellent drought tolerance and has yielded well in tests in Texas and Kansas.  TAM 111 should be available to seedsmen next year and to farmers in 2004.

Irrigated

Irrigated varieties that were in the top 20% at both the Hart and Dalhart locations were Cutter and Jagalene.  Jagalene is discussed under the dryland section.  Cutter is similar to Jagalene in that one of its parents is Jagger.  The other parent is the popular Ogallala variety.   Other varieties in the top 20% at one of the two locations were 2145, Above, AP 502 CL, Dumas, Trego, Ogallala, Stanton, TAM 105, TAM 302, and TAM 111.  2145 was released by Kansas in 2001.  This is the first year we have included this variety in our uniform variety trial.  2145 has Abilene as one of its parents and has leaf rust and soil-borne mosaic resistance.  Dumas is a new release from AgriPro that has performed well under irrigation in our trials the last two years.  TAM 302 has also been a high yielding irrigated wheat, however, its test weight is consistently low.

Standibility is an important consideration under full irrigation.  None of the top yielding wheats had a significant lodging problem in 2002.

TOP YIELD AVERAGES BY LOCATION OVER MULTIPLE YEARS

        Silverton                                 Canadian                           Hart/Dimmitt

        3-Yr Avg                        3-Yr Avg                2-Yr Avg

Scout 66           35 bu            Jagger              61 bu            Dumas              126 bu

TAM 105         34 bu            TAM 105         55 bu            Jagger              125 bu

Jagger              34 bu            Custer              52 bu            TAM 400         125 bu

TAM 110         34 bu            Tonkawa          52 bu            TAM 201         123 bu

When choosing a variety data should be examined over multiple years.  Three of the trials have been located with the same producer for at least two years.  The table shows the average yield of the top varieties in those trials.  County extension agents at these locations will have the complete summary for the 2 and 3 year averages.

Variety Recommendations

Each year is different.  For this reason, always look at yield data from at least three years before selecting a variety for planting.  It is also a good idea to plant more than one variety since varieties perform differently under various environmental conditions.  Some varieties also tend to perform better in different parts of the Panhandle.  Additional information on this years trials as well as results from previous years can be viewed at the following web site:  http://amarillo.tamu.edu/amaweb/Programs/Agronomy/publications/Wheat/index.htm

When considering a variety, characteristics such as plant height, disease and insect tolerance, coleoptile length (determines how deep the variety can be planted), and fall grazing potential should be considered along with yield data. Under dryland conditions it is hard to go wrong with Custer, Jagger, TAM 105, or TAM 110.  All four varieties have good yield histories under a wide range of conditions..  Custer and Jagger are considered good grazing wheats, and TAM 110 has greenbug tolerance.  Under full irrigation  Jagger, Ogallala, TAM 110, TAM 200 and TAM 202 should perform well under a wide range of conditions.  Other irrigated varieties to consider are TAM 302 and 2137.

Variety Recommendations

   Irrigated             Dryland

Jagger                 Custer

Ogallala                               Jagger

TAM 110            TAM 105

TAM 200            TAM 110

TAM 202

If next year some of the newer varieties continue to perform as well as they have the last two years my variety recommendation list will likely change.  Varieties to keep an eye on are Dumas, Jagalene, Cutter, TAM 400, and Stanton.

Common Bunt an Increasing Problem

Common bunt, also called stinking smut and covered smut, has become an increasing problem for a few producers the last couple of years.  Common bunt is NOT KARNAL BUNT.  Wheat seed infested with bunt spores will have a fishy odor.  A bunt ball, full of black spores replaces healthy kernels in the spike.  Once these bunt balls burst, black spores contaminate surrounding kernels.  Smutted grain is often discounted in value and may not be accepted at the market.  Common bunt persist as spores on seed and in the soil.  Cool fall temperatures favor infection.  Under the right conditions the wheat plant becomes infected as the seedling emerges from the soil.

Currently I am not aware of any varieties that are resistant to common bunt. From a cultural standpoint producers should avoid planting seed that originated from contaminated fields.  Seed is the primary method that common bunt is spread.  For those fields with a history of common bunt there are some seed treatments that are available that should provide some measure of control.  In infested fields, early planting when soil temperatures are warm , should decrease the degree of infection of emerging seedlings.

INFORMATION GIVEN HEREIN IS FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY.  REFERENCE TO COMMERCIAL PRODUCTS OR TRADE NAMES IS MADE WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT NO DISCRIMINATION IS INTENDED AND NO ENDORSEMENT BY THE COOPERATIVE EXTENSION SERVICE IS IMPLIED.



[1]Professor and Extension Agronomist, Amarillo.

Texas Cooperative Extension and Texas Agricultural Experiment Station
2001 – 2002 Wheat Variety Trials
DRYLAND
Investigators: Brent Bean, Mark Lazar, Jackie Rudd, Matt Rowland, Gary Peterson, Jonny Simmons
Wheat Yield*
Entry bu/Acre
No. Variety Silverton Canadian Bushland Etter Claude Average
1 2137 20.5 15.3 21.2 10.0 29.3 19.3
2 2145 20.1 10.0 22.8 10.8 24.0 17.5
3 2174 20.9 27.8 21.6 10.5 32.0 22.6
4 Above 25.6 29.7 24.0 10.6 42.1 26.4
5 AP 502 CL 26.5 32.8 22.5 10.5 37.6 26.0
6 Custer 20.2 28.3 24.2 9.0 35.3 23.4
7 Cutter 17.4 14.2 23.5 10.7 29.6 19.1
8 Dumas 17.2 23.6 23.2 11.9 24.7 20.1
9 Jagalene 21.1 28.9 24.3 9.4 33.7 23.5
10 Jagger 21.7 21.1 24.7 8.8 26.6 20.6
11 Trego (White wheat) 18.5 36.8 24.4 10.4 37.2 25.5
12 Intrada (White wheat) 18.7 28.0 23.9 10.3 27.6 21.7
13 Platte (White wheat) 21.4 30.6 20.9 7.2 25.3 21.1
14 Kalvesta 14.4 23.1 22.2 10.7 30.2 20.1
15 Lockett 9.4 7.3 18.6 5.9 27.4 13.7
16 Longhorn 10.3 17.3 19.2 7.5 25.6 16.0
17 Ogallala 16.2 17.9 22.7 10.0 23.6 18.1
18 OK101 15.2 19.8 21.9 9.6 31.6 19.6
19 Prairie Red 18.4 38.7 23.8 9.4 32.8 24.6
20 Scout 66 20.7 20.7 19.1 5.5 30.8 19.4
21 Stanton 26.8 28.4 25.6 7.8 28.8 23.5
22 TAM 105 22.6 39.8 20.7 9.4 29.4 24.4
23 TAM 107 22.8 32.4 20.4 7.2 34.2 23.4
24 TAM 109 15.4 31.1 20.2 7.3 21.5 19.1
25 TAM 110 22.4 28.5 23.1 12.9 32.5 23.9
26 TAM 200 15.6 28.6 22.6 8.3 28.4 20.7
27 TAM 201 13.0 29.4 17.1 2.4 20.4 16.5
28 TAM 202 15.8 26.4 25.8 9.2 28.4 21.1
29 TAM 302 12.0 34.9 21.4 6.7 22.0 19.4
30 TAM 400 16.2 26.8 21.8 8.1 24.5 19.5
31 Thunderbolt 14.5 20.2 22.4 10.4 27.5 19.0
32 Tonkawa 14.1 27.2 22.3 9.5 31.5 20.9
33 Triumph 64 19.1 20.1 19.5 6.1 29.0 18.8
34 TAM 111 25.1 25.8 24.2 7.9 29.6 22.5
35 Venango 20.1 17.5 22.7 10.5 28.3 19.8
Average 18.6 25.4 22.2 8.9 29.2 20.9
LSD (P=.05) 7.5 9.4 2.1 3.6 4.6
Standard Deviation 5.4 6.7 1.3 2.2 2.8
CV 28.1 26.1 5.8 25.1 9.3
*Bold type indicates yield was in the top 20%.
Texas Cooperative Extension and Texas Agricultural Experiment Station
2001 – 2002 Wheat Variety Trials
Irrigated
Investigators: Brent Bean, Mark Lazar, Jackie Rudd, Calvin Trostle, Matt Rowland, Gary Peterson, Jonny Simmons
Hart1) Dalhart1)
Entry Yield* Height Test Wt. Lodged Yield* Height Test Wt. Lodged
No. Variety bu/Ac Inches lb/bu % bu/Ac Inches lb/bu %
1 2137 123.2 41.5 62.3 0.0 62.7 25.0 57.6
2 2145 128.9 38.5 62.4 0.0 58.8 21.8 57.6
3 2174 114.2 39.3 62.4 0.0 62.1 24.8 59.7
4 Above 127.4 38.3 61.6 2.5 76.7 24.0 58.7
5 AP 502 CL 128.2 39.0 61.0 5.0 66.0 23.3 57.5
6 Custer 120.0 39.8 62.8 8.8 65.6 25.0 59.9
7 Cutter 128.6 42.0 63.5 2.5 75.0 26.0 59.4
8 Dumas 130.3 38.5 64.0 0.0 69.2 24.8 59.5
9 Jagalene 126.9 39.0 62.8 7.5 73.8 25.8 60.5
10 Jagger 130.4 38.3 61.9 10.0 72.9 26.0 58.5
11 Trego (White wheat) 104.5 38.5 61.9 35.0 77.7 24.8 61.2
12 Intrada (White wheat) 119.1 36.5 65.1 23.8 71.1 24.0 60.8
13 Platte (White wheat) 123.7 37.0 61.0 1.3 60.9 22.0 60.1
14 Kalvesta 113.9 37.3 61.9 26.3 68.5 24.5 59.2
15 Lockett 91.7 38.3 59.6 37.5 65.7 26.5 58.7 10
16 Longhorn 96.9 42.3 62.5 0.0 65.2 27.0 60.4
17 Ogallala 131.6 38.0 63.5 0.0 61.7 23.3 59.4
18 OK101 124.3 39.3 62.9 0.0 71.9 27.3 58.7
19 Prairie Red 111.0 38.3 60.9 27.5 72.3 24.8 59.2
20 Scout 66 81.0 41.3 61.0 83.8 62.1 29.3 60.8
21 Stanton 125.1 43.3 62.4 0.0 73.6 24.8 60.4
22 TAM 105 123.1 39.0 60.8 0.0 75.2 24.5 59.8
23 TAM 107 114.3 39.3 61.4 0.0 65.8 24.0 57.8
24 TAM 109 101.1 35.8 58.4 1.3 64.4 23.5 60.4
25 TAM 110 119.1 38.8 61.2 5.0 69.0 24.3 57.7
26 TAM 200 121.3 35.8 63.8 16.3 71.8 24.0 60.9
27 TAM 201 121.0 32.0 62.6 0.0 68.6 22.8 59.2
28 TAM 202 118.5 35.5 62.8 1.3 73.3 25.5 60.5
29 TAM 302 118.4 39.5 59.4 6.3 74.0 25.8 56.5
30 TAM 400 126.4 38.0 64.3 27.5 68.4 22.8 61.2
31 Thunderbolt 114.4 41.8 62.4 0.0 67.2 27.8 61.3
32 Tonkawa 109.5 42.5 62.8 0.0 67.5 26.0 60.8
33 Triumph 64 78.3 45.8 62.6 26.3 54.6 29.8 60.7
34 TAM 111 127.8 41.5 62.1 2.5 67.2 25.0 59.5
35 Venango 124.9 40.5 62.7 0.0 63.8 24.0 59.9
Average 117.1 39.1 62.1 10.2 68.1 25.0 59.5
LSD (P=.05) 11.8 2.5 1.1 21.7 10.7 28.7 1.4
Standard Deviation 8.4 1.8 0.8 15.5 7.6 20.5 1.0
CV 7.2 4.7 1.3 149.7 11.2 77.4 1.6
*Yields are reported at 13.5 % moisture.  Bold type indicates yields in the top 20%.
1)The Hart location received 19.5 inches of irrigation water and the Dalhart location received 17.5 inches.

Comments are closed.